1) Irina Movchan (UKR)
Music: Verano Portento
Total Score: 45.68 (SP) + 77.47 (FS) = 123.15
Music: Verano Portento
- I've not seen this skater before, she is gorgeous
- She seems very young and inexperienced
- I wish we could see more passion and intensity in her performance
- She kind of looks like she is just in practice right now
- Popped a double axel to a single
- She seems to be running out of steam
- In her combination spin, it doesn't seem she is holding each position long enough to achieve top levels
Total Score: 45.68 (SP) + 77.47 (FS) = 123.15
2) Elena Glebova (EST)
Music: Cappricio Espagno
- She had a lot of highs and lows in the warm-up
- She is a very sassy skater, especially in her Sex and the City short program
- Decent opening 3z
- Fall on 3lo
- Good double axel, singles the combination jump
- Another shaky 2a
- "shaky" is a good word for this program, she doesn't look confident in her landings
- Even her spins look wobbly and she is traveling
- I admire her effort and her flair in the choreography between elements
- Elena isn't thrilled with that overall
FS Score: 38.29 (TES) + 41.21 (PCS) - 1.00 (DED) = 78.50
Total Score: 46.28 (SP) + 78.50 (FS) = 124.78
3) Viktoria Helgesson (SWE)
Music: The Drummer/Sad Romance/ August Rhapsody
- The Helgesson sisters are coached by their mother; Joshi had the better short program here
- Popped her opening jump, not a good way to make up ground after a poor short
- Hand down on 3F, adds two doubles to make a series
- Nice strong 3lo to recover
- This is a gorgeous musical selection and it suits her style very well
- I'd love to see more freedom in this footwork sequence, she is concentrating so hard
- That spiral could use a lot more stretch
- Good 3T
- Another strong 3lz, but hardly any speed coming out to get into the 2T
- I love this August's Rhapsody section, she seems to be hitting her stride here
- She saved a lot of jumps for the second half so she'll get extra credit
FS Score: 49.94 (TES) + 47.18 (PCS) - (DED) = 97.12
Total Score: 45.40 (SP) + 97.12 (FS) = 142.52
4) Juulia Turkkila (FIN)
Music: Don Quixote
- I have Juulia on my fantasy team so I'm pulling for a great skate
- Good opening double axel
- I'd like to see her pick up the speed
- Nice 3lo-3T combination
- A solid 3s-3t combination
- The speed isn't great, but so far a clean skate
- She has nice posture and the look of a ballerina on the ice
- She is only 16 so this is a good youthful musical selection for her
- Good double axel
- She is replacing the injured Laura Lepisto at worlds and she is doing a fine job
- It is great to see that Finland is building a talented ladies field
- She is fizzling off toward the end, needs to keep her energy up
- That crossed leg sit spin position was really interesting
- The crowd is getting behind her in this footwork
- Great clean skate overall, she is very pleased!
FS Score: 46.91 (TES) + 44.07 (PCS) - (DED) = 90.98
Total Score: 45.70 (SP) + 90.98 (FS) = 136.68
5) Bingwa Geng (CHN)
Music: Red Violin
- Bingwa has been up and down all season so I'm hoping for a solid skate from her
- Yuna Kim is her idol so it must be quite an experience for her to skate in the same competition
- A fall on the opening 3z
- Good strong 3T
- Nice 2A to recover
- Let's hope she's found her stride now
- Two solid 3-2 combinations with only slightly shaky landings
- It's good to see her finally finding her stride
- I wish she could pick up some more speed
- She is really trying to use her entire body for expression in this footwork
- She is concentration so hard and that shows on her face; I'd like more of a performance
- Her 2a covers a decent amount of ice
- Slow camel spin, but it picks up speed when she hits the donut position
FS Score: 50.93 (TES) + 42.96 (PCS) - 1.00 (DED) = 92.89
Total Score: 47.89 (SP) + 92.89 (FS) = 140.78
6) Jenna McCorkell (GBR)
Music: Voice of Violins/Allegro from Music for Strings
- Jenna has been up and down all season but she looked good in warm-up
- She is married to Kevin Van Der Perren
- She is taller for a skater and can build good speed with those long lets
- Awkward 3Z, but solid 3F to follow
- Hands down and turn out of 3T
- None of her landings are really happening correctly for her today
- She doesn't seem to be working to interpret this music, all she is doing is smiling
- She looks exhausted by the end of this footwork and her limbs are flailing
- She is not happy with that performance at all
FS Score: 33.55 (TES) + 42.22 (PCS) - (DED) = 75.77
Total Score: 45.99 (SP) + 75.77 (FS) = 121.76
7) Cheltzie Lee (AUS)
Music: Yentl
- Is she going to channel Barbra?
- She took it easy in the warm-up, which is understandable for skating first
- She is very expressive, particularly with her upper body, straight from the top
- Good 3f-3t-2t from the beginning
- Bails out and two-foots the 3z
- Could use more speed in that sit spin
- She is really focused; she'll need more reckless abandon to channel Barbra
- Good 3T
- She looks very unsure in all of her jump landings
- Step out of 3S-2T
- She needs to stretch in her neck and drop her shoulders
- Needs much more stretch in spiral
- 2a is the very las movement of the program, hand down
FS Score: 42.85 (TES) + 42.60 (PCS) - (DED) = 85.45
Total Score: 48.20 (SP) + 85.45 (FS) = 133.65
8) Elene Gedevanishvili (GEO)
Music: Phantom of the Opera
- Nice solid 3z-2t to open
- She has good speed and flow across the ice
- Strong 3z
- She is so hit or miss because right now she looks strong
- I clearly spoke to soon because she fell on the 3F
- I hate Andrew Lloyd Webber
- 2a into a 3 jump series
- 4 of her jumping passes are out of the way in the first minute
- She is very expressive with her face and arms
- She needs to shake out her hands before she skates so they don't clench up like claws
- Good strong solo 2a
- I adore this costume
- The Masquerade music is a good choice for the foot sequence
- She is definitely showing that she is a fighter with this program
- There is nothing tentative about her skating and she attacks everything
FS Score: 54.66 (TES) + 50.97 (PCS) - 1.00 (DED) = 104.63
Total Score: 51.61 (SP) + 104.63 (FS) = 156.24
9) Amelie Lacoste (CAN)
Music: Sheherazade
- I hate how she stays still for those opening notes, they are so dynamic and are dying for movement
- 2 strong 2a's with a stumble on one
- Popped open the 3z
- I love the wally entrance into the 3F, her feet get tangled and a hand must go down
- She could use a lot more stretch in the spiral
- I love that she uses her arms well and is so strong, but I want to see more on her face
- Fall on 3T
- She made such a strong debut this season with a bronze at Skate Canada; such a shame she couldn't find that magic the rest of the season
FS Score: 44.58 (TES) + 48.20 (PCS) - 1.00 (DED) = 92.78
Total Score: 51.98 (SP) + 92.78 (FS) = 144.76
10) Ira Vannut (BEL)
Music: Children of Dune
- Very tilted in the air on her opening 3z, couldn't save the landing
- This costume is too over the top for me, with the gloves and all its too much red
- I want to see some expression on her face
- I want her to turn out that foot on the layback spin
- She is in dire need of some ballet to help her skate more elegantly
- Is that pink underneath her costume? Why is that necessary?
- I feel that she is just going through the motions and is not engaged at all with the performance
- She really needs to stretch through those fee in her spins so they don't look like they are just hanging off of her legs
FS Score: 47.31 (TES) + 42.74 (PCS) - 1.00 (DED) = 89.05
Total Score: 49.23 (SP) + 89.05 (FS) = 138.28
11) Joshi Helgesson (SWE)
Music: Palladio/Feeling Good
- I love Joshi, she's had a great season so far
- She takes a very hard fall on her opening 3z
- Nice 3S to get back into it
- I admire that she didn't let the fall hurt her and she is still putting 100% into the performance
- She seems to really enjoy this footwork
- She needs to keep her speed up because its one of the best things about her skating
- She is definitely the more athletic of the Helgesson sisters while Viktoria is more elegant
- She seems to have the crowd on her side
- I love the way she attacks every element
- Aside from the fall, what a great free skate
- She and her coaches seems so pleased
FS Score: 53.47 (TES) + 46.36 (PCS) - 1.00 (DED) = 98.83
Total Score: 50.25 (SP) + 98.83 (FS) = 149.08
12) Cynthia Phaneuf (CAN)
Music: Rhapsody on a Theme by Paganini
- She needs to do well here to hold onto 2 ladies spots for Canada at 2012 worlds
- Nice strong 3T
- Very tilted in the air, falls on 3z
- I wish she would've picked a stronger piece of music; her short is much better suited for her
- She has really good speed
- She is popping jumps now, she is losing her concentration
- This won't be the 5th place finish she had last season
- It has to be a lot of pressure to go out and know that your teammate didn't skate well and that it falls on your shoulders to hold onto the spots
FS Score: 47.94 (TES) + 53.22 (PCS) - 1.00 (DED) = 100.16
Total Score: 52.26 (SP) + 100.16 (FS) = 152.78
13) Sarah Hecken (GER)
Music: Zazdrosc i Medycyna/Smuga Cienia/Revolutionary Etude
- Sarah is probably the surprise of this group
- A fine opening so far
- Her entrances are very long, I'd like to see more choreography into the jumps
- She really needs to concentrate on pointing her feet, they are especially noticeable in spins
- She is really committing to this footwork which is great to see
- Some of her spin positions are truly heinous, skaters shouldn't sacrifice beauty for levels
FS Score: 53.88 (TES) + 50.22 (PCS) - 1.00 (DED) = 103.10
Total Score: 52.73 (SP) + 103.10 (FS) = 155.83
14) Kiira Korpi (FIN)
Music: Evita
- Nice 3t-3t; redemption from the short program
- Great jump on that flying sit spin
- After a doubled triple and a fall, this will not be the clean free that she wanted
- That spiral position really needs to be stretched out
- I would have worn a white dress rather than purple
- Another double
- The catch foot is a nice spin position, but that ending was very abrupt
FS Score: 52.65 (TES) + 58.06 (PCS) - 1.00 (DED) = 109.71
Total Score: 55.09 (SP) + (FS) = 164.80
15) Kanako Murakami (JPN)
Music: The Mask of Zorro
- So she changed her fabulous short program costume but kept this mess?
- Nice 3-3
- Now this looks like the Kanako we've been seeing all season, very solid
- She has nothing to lose, starting in 10th, so its good to see her going all out
- Fairly nice stretch on her spiral
- A single flip, that certainly won't do
- I wonder how she feels about skating before her idol Mao
- She looks pleased and if she is happy, I'm happy
FS Score: 55.62 (TES) + 56.62 (PCS) - (DED) = 112.62
Total Score: 54.86 (SP) + 112.62 (FS) = 167.10
16) Mao Asada (JPN)
Music: Liebestraum
- Here comes one of the two headliners
- The 3a looked two-footed to me
- This lyrical program suits Mao so much better than her short
- Does Mao always wear long sleeves?
- You can tell Mao has a ballet background by looking at her arms
- A bit wild on the camel spin, but she controls it by the sit spin
- 2a-3t (two-footed)
- Mao you can't pop jumps like that if you want to move up; she's letting it get away
- Nice spiral position
- I can see she isn't completely happy
- Nice to see a little smile though
FS Score: 54.19 (TES) + 59.94 (PCS) - (DED) = 114.13
Total Score: 58.66 (SP) + 114.13 (FS) = 172.79
17) Mae Berenice Meite (FRA)
Music: Concertino pour guitare/Hable con ella/Fiesta Flamenca
- Wow after a great short, she is struggling with a fall and a huge stumble in the opening sequence of jumps
- Her footwork seems so slow
- Her leg is wrapped very high in these jumps which slows rotation
- Another stumble, this just is not her day
- But either way, that good short shows she can hang with the top skaters and sets her up well for next year
- The faster part of this music suits her better than the opening
FS Score: 50.63 (TES) + 47.55 (PCS) - 1.00 (DED) = 97.18
Total Score: 53.26 (SP) + 150.44 (FS) = 150.44
18) Rachael Flatt (USA)
Music: Slaughter on Tenth Avenue
- This new costume adds a level of elegance
- 2a-3t (maybe under-rotated and stumble, hand down)
- Popped 3F
- She needs perfection from here on out to help team USA
- 2a was nice
- She needs to eek out every fraction of a point right now
- Another popped Flip; has to be related to the injury
- This score is just not going to be pretty at all
- And she will not be held up by PCS like some of the other skater
FS Score: 45.45 (TES) + 51.94 (PCS) - (DED) = 97.39
Total Score: 57.22 (SP) + 97.39 (FS) =154.61
19) Miki Ando (JPN)
Music: Piano Concerto in A minor by Grieg
- I think Miki is going to give this all she possibly has in the tank
- I don't see her letting go of any easy points
- I think her flexibility has improved
- She is so focused, but I'd love to see a bit of that smile we saw in the short
- She started doubling some jumps, so she definitely did not give her best performance of the season
FS Score: 65.75 (TES) + 64.46 (PCS) - (DED) = 130.21
Total Score: 65.58 (SP) + 130.21 (FS) = 195.79
20) Alena Leonova (RUS)
Music: The Witches of Eastwick
- The costume, hair, gloves, it all looks like a tacky drag show
- Very solid triple-triple
- She has hit everything so far
- I don't like anything about this program or performance, but must admit she is looking solid
- This is the tackiest thing I've ever seen, but she landed the jumps and she'll score well
- Its great to see such unbridled happiness; Irina Slutskaya loved it too
FS Score: 62.35 (TES) + 61.82 (PCS) - (DED) = 124.17
Total Score: 59.75 (SP) + 124.17 (FS) = 183.92
21) Yuna Kim (KOR)
Music: Homage to Korea
- THE QUEEN
- This program is an homage to Korea, the homeland
- Amazing 3z-3t
- Such gorgeous flow and glide across the ice
- That was what, 2a-1t?
- This is a gorgeous piece of music
- 1F
- 2a-2-2 sequence
- This is the Yuna Kim we should have seen at the first grand prix of the season, not at Worlds
- Her basic skills are so fantastic that she can afford jumping mistakes and still be okay
- It looks like she has lost flexibility in her spiral
- I would love to see more passion on her face since this piece is so near to her heart
FS Score: 61.72 (TES) + 66.87 (PCS) - (DED) = 128.59
Total Score: 65.91 (SP) + 128.59 (FS) = 194.50
22) Alissa Czisny (USA)
Music: Winter and Spring by George Winston
- Come on Alissa!!
- I love that opening moment where she just takes her time to breathe
- Fall on the opening jump, this cannot bode well
- Nice 3-2 combination
- 3-2-2 sequence
- She looks very nervous, I want to see her face light up
- If the opening jump was fully rotated and she can avoid edge calls, she may be able to hang in
- Old Alissa would have crumbled after one fall, but this is new Alissa
- Gorgeous despite that one pesky fall
FS Score: 60.65 (TES) + 61.13 (PCS) - 1.00 (DED) = 120.78
Total Score: 61.47 (SP) + 120.78 (FS) = 182.25
23) Carolina Kostner (ITA)
Music: Afternoon of a Fawn
- This program is so unbelievably boring
- There is no drama to the music so you need a very nuanced performer, which she is not
- She normally tanks the free skate but she's been unusually clean today aside from a few bobbles
- If she medals I'm going to vomit
FS Score: 60.30 (TES) + 64.63 (PCS) - (DED) = 124.93
Total Score: 59.75 (SP) + 124.93 (FS) = 184.68
24) Ksenia Makarova (RUS)
Music: Evita
- Yay so far so good!
- She has really grown up as a performer this season!
- I want her on the podium so bad!!
- She needs to keep fighting for every fraction of a point
- Very hard fall
- Nice 2a-2-2 sequence
- She may still hang on for a medal
- She is such a little fighter out there
- Nice 2a to end her jumps
- Her spins are positions are much improved this season
- I like when she goes into the Buenos Aires section for footwork
- The sound design of her Evita is far superior to that of Korpi
FS Score: 46.52 (TES) + 60.08 (PCS) - 1.00 (DED) = 105.60
Total Score: 61.62 (SP) + 105.60 (FS) = 167.22
thanks for the live PBP!
ReplyDeleteim gutted for Yuna and Alena, absolute crap judging IMO..
Great commentary, thank you!
ReplyDelete-- Mathman :)
Ando, No emotion. no 3-3. her musicality is practically nonexistant.
ReplyDeleteAndo's program was very slow...I thought she'd stop in the middle. no 3-3. political bullshit like German commentator said.
ReplyDelete