Showing posts with label konstantin menshov. Show all posts
Showing posts with label konstantin menshov. Show all posts

Monday, November 14, 2011

2011 ISU Grand Prix of Figure Skating: NHK Trophy Mens Free Skate Commentary

1) Tomas Verner (CZE)                              
     Music: Sing Sing Sing, La Vie En Rose
  • He is looking like a totally different skater out there today
  • When he is on, he reminds me so much if Ilia Kulike
  • I like this program on him a lot, it reminds me of his Singin in the Rain
  • That was a horrifying fall on the triple axel, landing in a split position
  • I'm surprised he can continue after that fall
  • I'm not surprised he doubled his triple axel
  • Oh wow we're taking the suspenders down for the footwork
  • Oh no, another footwork fall
  • What a shame because it was a great 1st half of the program
  • This will be a hit by Europeans and Worlds if he can clean it up
FS Score: 63.89 (TES) + 71.78 (PCS) -2.00 (DED) = 133.67
Total Score: 62.96 (SP) + 133.67 (FS) =196.63

2) Armin Mahbanoozadeh (USA)
     Music: Kill Bill
  • Good glide out of the triple lutz
  • Nice glide out of the triple axel into steps
  • I like this music a lot, I can see it being a hit by Nationals
  • He does a good job of using his whole body in the footwork
  • I like the intensity and variation in the music, but his performance is lacking spark
  • He needs to find a way of connecting with the music
  • Straighten your leg and point your foot in the sit position please
  • Unfortunate fall halfway through, and he was going so strong!
  • Still needs work, but a huge improvement from Skate America!
FS Score: 61.12 (TES) + 61.94 (PCS) -1.00 (DED) = 122.06
Total Score: 63.52 (SP) + 122.06 (FS) = 185.58

3) Samuel Contesti (ITA)
     Music: La Vie En Rose, Ca Gaze
  • This was a great program at Skate America
  • He is such a tall skater that it's hard for him to not look hunched when he tries to get deep into the ice
  • Really high triple axel
  • Suspenders are the accessory of the season
  • He uses his performance skills to his advantage by always doing character programs
  • Both of these pieces of music work together so well
  • He has such a love for the sport and that shows out on the ice
  • Not too many other people make their 3axel their 3-jump combination
  • He's really playing to the crowd in this step sequence
  • He's a little stiff in his upper body, I'd like to see him relax there a bit
  • He music really speeds up at the end, but unfortunately his final spin can't match the speed
FS Score: 74.52 (TES) + 71.34 (PCS) = 145.86
Total Score: 63.83 (SP) + 145.86 (FS) = 209.69

4) Ross Miner (USA)
     Music: The Untouchables
  • This was a strong skate at Skate Canada
  • His hair looks a little messy today
  • He has great body lines
  • Beautiful triple axel into a pirouetting move
  • Another nice triple axel
  • I love that he becomes a character in this story
  • Step out of the triple lutz, a little too much speed going in
  • I love the headless variation of the scratch spin
  • He is carrying a ton of speed
  • He looks a little stiff on his jump landings
  • I'd love to see deeper knees in his landings
  • This is a very complete program, very majestic
  • Very nice outing for him
  • He fought for a few landings, but that builds character
  • He's quite happy with this skate!
FS Score: 74.22 (TES) + 67.02 (PCS) = 141.24
Total Score: 71.12 (SP) + 141.24 (FS) = 212.36

5) Tatsuki Machida (JPN)
     Music: Don Quixote
  • He is so small and sprightly!
  • He SAVED that jump!
  • He's a very  nice skater with great expression
  • Pops the axel
  • The jumps aren't all there and most will probably receive negative GOE's but that doesnt detract from the fact that this is a nice program
  • He could use a lot more speed in this step sequence
  • Nice ending pose
FS Score: 54.57 (TES) + 68.62 (PCS) = 123.19
Total Score: 72.26 (SP) + 123.19 (FS) = 195.45

6) Konstantin Menshov (RUS)
     Music: The Race, Kill Bill
  • This is interesting sound design to say the least
  • His jumps are huge, but really ugly in the air
  • This program is so Russian
  • Hard fall to the hip, slid off the landing edge
  • Another hard fall to the hip
  • These jumps are so big he can't maintain control
  • He has not 1 ounce of expression on his face
  • Very slow spins 
  • That flexed foot is so ugly
  • Well this is a string of huge jumps and that's about it
FS Score: 58.57 (TES) + 64.64 (PCS) -2.00 (DED) = 121.21
Total Score: 74.67 (SP) + 121.21 (FS) = 195.88

7) Brandon Mroz (USA)
     Music: Carmen
  • Very tilted in the air on the Quad Lutz, falls
  • Hand down on the triple axel
  • I hate to say it, but jumps are all he has
  • He can't fall back on PCS when he misses jumps
  • He needs to point the feet on the sit spin
  • He has no expression on his face
  • His disappointment over the jumps is ruining this program
  • Singles the axel, this program is really going nowhere fast
  • If you're using overdone music you need to make it fresh, and this is not
  • Another popped axel
  • Has all the focus on the Quad lutz distracted him from the rest of his skating?
  • Yet another popped jump, this is painful to watch, I feel for him
  • I'd love to know how coaches inspire their athletes after meltdowns like that
FS Score: 45.44 (TES) + 65.56 (PCS) -1.00 (DED) = 110.00
Total Score: 74.83 (SP) + 110.00 (FS) = 184.83

8) Takahiko Kozuka (JPN)
     Music: The Valley of the Wind
  • I love that back pat that Sato gives Taka
  • I'd love to see him in a more modern costume
  • His expression has improved so much this season
  • Two-foots the Quad Toe
  • Good triple axel on a really deep leg
  • His improvement from Skate America to NHK is amazing!
  • This home crowd has really helped him to regain his confidence
  • That was a gigantic triple axel! 3-jump combo
  • I really like this choreography
  • Ends a little before the music
  • It wasn't perfect, but it was such an improvement
FS Score: 76.67 (TES) + 78.56 (PCS) = 155.25
Total Score: 79.77 (SP) + 155.25 (FS) = 235.02

9) Daisuke Takahshi (JPN)
     Music: Blues for Klook
  • Goes for the Quad Flip, falls
  • Amazing triple axel
  • I don't love all of his spin positions
  • All of his "in betweens" are the highlights of his programs
  • If there was ever a case for solo ice dance, it's Takahashi
  • His jumps are always a little questionable, but he's solid today
  • He just has the crowd in the palm of his hand
  • If he didn't have to do jumps and could just get credit for like 10 step sequences it would be a dream come true
  • He is overcome with the emotion of this crowd
FS Score: 80.04 (TES) + 90.28 (PCS)  -1.00 (DED) = 169.32
Total Score: 90.43 (SP) + 169.32 (FS) = 259.75

Monday, November 7, 2011

2011 NHK Trophy: Men's Preview

This is always a great event, simply because Japan has great men's talent, never mind the rest of the field. The men's competition is the headlining event in Japan, which is unfortunately the middle of the night here in the US. We'll see the short program Saturday November 12th at 2:30 a.m. EST and the free skate at 10:55 p.m. EST the same day.
Daisuke Takahashi (JPN) is the reigning champion in this event and has quite a good chance of repeating. Both of his programs are stylish and innovative, specifically his bluesy free skate. His TES & PCS in both programs from Skate Canada this year outscore those of his biggest competitor Takahiko Kozuka (JPN) from Skate America. Neither man put together two clean programs in his first Grand Prix, but Takahashi's programs seem to have more potential, especially in program components. Brandon Mroz (USA) can be a podium threat if he lands his now famous Quad Lutz cleanly. He is a strong jumper and needs to pull really high GOE marks to make up for the higher PCS marks some of the other competitors will pull in. His personal best score came last season in his first Grand Prix, so he has a good shot at debuting strong again this season. Tomas Verner (CZE) was all over the place last season, from exquisitely entertaining to downright sloppy.  If we get "Good Tomas" he is almost guaranteed the podium, but if not, he could finished near the bottom. Ross Miner (USA) is a fighter and after finishing 9/10 in the short program at Skate Canada, he came back with a strong 5th in the free skate. He has a lovely long program this season and though he does not have a Quad, he almost always receives positive GOEs on his triples as well as level 4 spins. Tatsuki Machida (JPN), Konstantin Menshov (RUS), Armin Mahbanoozadeh (USA), Samuel Contesti (ITA) were all up and down last season and each has podium potential if they can skate both programs to the best of their ability and hope for mistakes from the top contenders. We'll call this "pulling a Van Der Perren" in reference to his surprise silver at Skate America this season.

My Podium Predictions:
1) Daisuke Takahashi (JPN)
2) Takahiko Kozuka (JPN)
3) Brandon Mroz (USA)


Competitive History: 


Samuel Contesti (ITA)-3rd 2011 O Nepela, 18th 2011 Worlds, 6th 2011 Europeans, 1st 2011 Mont Blanc Trophy, 4th 2010 NRW Trophy, 4th 2010 Cup of Russia, 4th 2010 Cup of China, 3rd 2010 Finlandia Trophy; PB: 226.97 at 2009 Worlds


Takahiko Kozuka (JPN)-3rd at 2011 Skate America, 2nd 2011 Worlds, 4th 2011 Four Continents, 3rd 2010 Grand Prix Final, 1st 2010 Trophee Eric Bompard, 1st 2010 Cup of China; PB: 258.41 at 2011 Worlds


Tatsuki Machida (JPN)-1st 2011 Triglav Trophy, 4th 2011 Asian Winter Games, 11th 2010 Rostelecom Cup, 5th 2010 Cup of China, 1st 2010 Nebelhorn Trophy; PB: 217.48 at 2010 Four Continents

Armin Mahbanoozadeh (USA)-10th at 2011 Skate America, 7th 2011 Four Continents, 3rd 2010 Skate America, 4th Nebelhorn Trophy; 211.17 at 2010 Skate America



Konstantin Menshov (RUS)-7th 2011 Nebelhorn Trophy, 7th 2011 Europeans, 10th 2010 Rostelecom Cup, 2nd 2010 Coup de Nice, 6th 2010 Finlandia Trophy, 2nd 2010 Nebelhorn Trophy; PB: 202.62 at 2011 Europeans

Ross Miner (USA)-6th at 2011 Skate Canada, 11th at 2011 Worlds, 7th at 2010 Cup of China, 9th at 2010 NHK Trophy; PB: 217.93 at 2011 Worlds

Brandon Mroz (USA)-3rd 2010 Trophee Eric Bompard, 2nd 2010 Cup of China; PB: 216.80 at 2010 Cup of China



Daisuke Takahashi (JPN)-3rd at 2011 Skate Canada, 5th at 2011 Worlds, 1st at 2011 Four Continents, 4th at 2010 Grand Prix Final, 1st at 2010 Skate America, 1st at 2010 NHK Trophy; PB: 264.41 at 2008 Four Continents


Tomas Verner (CZE)-12th 2011 Worlds, 3rd 2011 Europeans, 5th 2010 Grand Prix Final,
1st 2010 Rostelecom Cup, 3rd 2010 Cup of China; PB: 232.67 at 2008 Europeans