Wednesday, June 29, 2011

So You Think You Can Dance: The Top 16 Perform!

Here we are again, its Wednesday at 8 and that could only mean one thing....this is So You Think You Can Dance. Tonight the top 16 perform and Kristin Chenoweth (my favorite) is guest judging.

9:56 Well that was it for me. I'm going to do some thinking and post my recap and my predictions tomorrow. Until then, happy dancing!
9:54 I expected this to be a crazy aggressive song but I think the softness actually suits it well. Maida Withers would say that it is was way too symmetrical
9:53 Battle of the Sexes, part....how many? PS this is a very cool piece, Dee's stock just went up in my mind!
9:52 First I thought this piece was about snap cups; Dee why couldn't you have done this for a duet instead of that damn piano man piece
9:50 I wanted to give a special shout-out to my follower from the UK who has hit my blog so many times tonight! Come back again and see us soon!
9:47 I feel like Kristin is putting on a little bit of a "tv personality" tonight....I don't think she is being completely "real Kristin"
9:45 Sometimes when a choreographer comes up with a "concept" it can be dangerous...just ask Baayork Lee
9:44 They are really killing this routine; I like the play on "jumping on the bed" because we all did that when we were kids
9:43 The movement is actually pretty good, and the changes of clothes are a really cool idea
9:42 Okay so we are doing a hip-hop version of "the morning after?" hmmmm.....its inventive I'll give you that
9:35 Thank the lord they kept those 2 last week, they have so much growing to do and tonight was a huge step in the right direction
9:34 Lil C is clearly president of the Sonya fan club
9:33 Is Ryan not wearing any makeup? She needs a little something more on the face
9:32 I like how understated this piece was, not a lot of tricks, just some nice quiet dancing
9:31 This piece is very quiet, I get the message they are communicating and it is great to see Ryan expressing something other than a smile
9:31 Sonya has used that same 2-rotation lift in both pieces tonight, just in different body positions
9:30 It brings an interesting angle that the two have never been in love before but they're creating a piece about losing else they've loved in their lives
9:29 Ryan was like me....her mom put her into dance to bring her out of her shell
9:28 Ryan & Ricky are like my goofy favorites; I feel like they are the slow ones of the bunch and always out to lunch but I want to be their best friends
9:24 Sinatra can make anyone look good
9:22 The Foxtrot was Kristin's favorite dance of the night; she just labeled them Fred & Ginger
9:21 That was a spot on Foxtrot according to Mary, did she just call her "Clarence"
9:21 Jess is not the strongest partner and the lifts still look heavy and clunky; part of me thinks that it is his diva attitude not wanting to let her be the center of attention
9:20 Nice lines and nice fluidity. I love the little West Side Story side kick moment
9:19 This is so classic but Jess looks so short next to Clarice in heels, especially when he is lifting her
9:18 Going back to the Sonya piece....the reason I praised the competition was because I couldn't praise the choreography
9:14 By the way, if you hate what i'm saying or love what i'm saying, please feel free to let me know in the comments section below and we can get a dialogue going! Or tweet me @barbiebackstage
9:11 Kristin's comment was convoluted for me, she couldn't comment on it because she didn't understand the style? I'm confused
9:09 I'll agree with Nigel that the performance was 100% committed but I disagree that the music was a wrong choice because A) That is not under the dancers' control and B) this is the kind of material Sonya does so that's what you get when you commission a routine from her
9:08 Sonya is a master of composition. This duet is very well fomatted with side-by-side movement, individual movement, and partnering
9:07 In the side-by-side unison movement, Chris is slightly behind Ashley and isn't quite punching the movements as hard as she is. This music has really cool undertones. I like the whole use Ashley as a puppet thing
9:07 Sonya pieces must be so fun to perform once you finally get the choreography down pat
9:06 Is Ashley wearing a onezie?
9:05 Sonya is craxy as all get out and I just love it, she is truly original
9:00 And Krazy Aunt Kristin just laid a bit smooch on Lil C....like we didn't see that coming
8:59 Thank god Kristin just hit a signature high note and gave us her signature phrase "we sing because we can't speak anymore, and dance is an extension of that"
8:58 Oh hell no Nigel just macked on Mary! Krazy Aunt Kristin doesn't know what just happened
8:57 Nigel just labeled Melanie & Marko "the couple to beat" #duh
8:56 Tabitha's doppleganger is most definitely Stacey London
8:55 It most definitely was "buck"  -Lil C
8:54 These two are on of those partnerships that only happens maybe once in a season and they are both such bright lights for dance!
8:53 These two have some amazing chemistry and that is so the key to making it far in the competiion
8:52 Lyrical hip-hop by Nappytabs...a piece about 2 friends...now that's a new concept. Basically "Man of Honor"
8:51 Melanie & Marko were both little divas when they started dancing
8:44 Nigel gives us a shout out to Vincent Minelli #work
8:44 Lil C: "Miranda, with legs like that, who needs arms?"
8:42 So here is my thing Tyce, why choose music with built in tap sounds and not have them tap? And do ladies of the night always do aerials?
8:41 Oh yay we love Sophisticated Ladies! Right off the bat,  Miranda is not committing enough to the character. Robert is lighting ig up in his role but Miranda looks like she is out to lunch
8:40 Hello there Tyce: so Miranda is playing a hooker and Robert is a groovy cat
8:39 I think I had almost the exact costume that Miranda wore in her first show.
8:33 Nigel just called Mitchell "the Chris Rock of dance"....is that a compliment?
8:32 I love Aunt Kristin "you shut it down, you shut your legs, you opened your legs"
8:31 So Mary had a stroke? She forgot Caitlynn's name and is forgetting how to speak English
8:29 This routine is so clunky. The music isn't helping, but everything looks awkward and forced, nothing is smooth.
8:28 Caitlynn has nice straight legs and pointed feet in that opening helicopter lift; is it just me or is this piece moving really slowly? So Caitlynn is whipping her hair and her skirt a lot while Mitchell is actually dancing. Is that the name of the game?
8:27 Caitlynn & Mitchell Samba with Jean-Marc; this best be hot
8:27 Holy crap Mitchell didn't start dancing until he was 16
8:26 I can relate to Caitlynn on the horrible costume front
8:24 To quote my friend @Kyle_Louise "where was the dancing there? if you blinked you missed it"
8:20 Lil C just called Sasha "8 notches above perfection"; so the judges loved Sasha and Alex was invisible? Did I hear that correctly?
8:19 Aunt Kristin always has the best stories: "I played a flower and a frog peed on me"
8:18 That piece was a collection of lovely images and photo opportunities, but choreography? Not so much...
8:15 I kind of love the opening image with Alex at the piano. Sasha is just so present in her own body. Wow he is throwing her all over that piano! I'm not cool with disrespecting my favorite instrument, but for the sake of art I'll allow it. That last image with her hands coming through the back of the piano was haunting!
8:14 I'm so happy to see Dee Caspary back, he's working with Sasha & Alex. Surprise, surprise, it is a love story, but it looks like a unique twist so we'll see.
8:12 And some more tacky introductions, but at least "the first performance" is poignant. Sasha was a frog in Thumbelina, aka wearing a green unitard. Alex did a tribute to The Lion King at his 6th birthday party.
8:07 Every time I want to "hit the road" I always do a back handspring series. Tyce the genius
8:06 The lighting is so dark that i can barely tell what is going on in the routine...but now that I can see the movement, it's not doing much for me
8:06 I so thought that this was going to be Cell Block Tango because Tyce is trite like that
8:05 Tyce is such a jerk-wad....if you want a better explanation just watch Every Little Step, a documentary about the revival of A Chorus Line
8:04 OMG Kristin & Lil C are going to be best friends...its so going to happen...watch out twitter!
8:03 Get it Kristin Chenoweth! That's my girl right there....my idol...the person I aspire to become!
8:02 Our dancers are doing their intro dances as couples tonight instead of solos, very sassafrass
8:01 It's going to feel weird going from 10 routines to 8
8:00 Cat Deeley is looking so glam tonight......very Roxie Hart!

Madison Chock & Evan Bates Team Up

 Isn't it rich? Are they a pair? After all the recent splits in pairs skating and ice dance in the US and world-wide, a new team has emerged. Though USFSA hasn't made an official announcement, Jo Ann Barnes of the Detroit Free Press announced this morning in an article that Madison Chock (formerly with Greg Zuerlein who retired) has teamed with Evan Bates (formerly with Emily Samuelson with whom he split for unknown reasons). One thing this team has going for them is that both, with there former partners, trained with Zoueva & Shpilband in Canton, MI so no moves or coaching changes are in order. Igor Shpilband commented earlier this week that Madison had tryouts with several other ice dancers and I'd love to know who they were. I haven't had a lot of time to process this new pairing but here are my initial thoughts:

1) The height difference: Madison is 5'1" and Evan is 6'2" which would be great in pairs but may be awkward in the close holds of ice dancing. On the flip side, this could make for some impressive lifts, which Madison lacked with the much shorter Zuerlein.
2) Injuries: Is Evan truly healed from his achilles injury? I initially suspected the reason he split from Emily was that he was not yet ready to compete, though this new pairing would suggest that he is.
3) Style: Though Madison is a beautiful skater, she doesn't have the long clean lines of Emily Samuelson, which was one of the things that made her a great match for Evan. On the other side, Madison is incredibly expressive, even to the point of chewing scenery, while Evan is a bit more reserved as a performer.
4) Status: Oddly enough many expected Chock/Zuerlein & Samuelson/Bates to compete for the 3rd slot in the US behind Davis/White & Shibutani/Shibutani. Since the two teams split and re-teamed, if they can mesh well by January, they are almost guaranteed that 3rd spot on the US podium and a bid to Worlds. USA also has 2 host picks left for Skate America and this team will more than likely get one of them.

Monday, June 27, 2011

2011 ISU Grand Prix of Figure Skating Assignments



Skate America (Oct 21-23)
Ladies:
Elene Gedevanishvili, GEO
Carolina Kostner, ITA
Valentina Marchei, ITA
Haruka Imai, JPN
Ksenia Makarova, RUS
Joshi Helgesson, SWE
Viktoria Helgesson, SWE
Alissa Czisny, USA
Caroline Zhang, USA
Joelle Forte, USA
Mens: 
Kevin van der Perren, BEL
Michal Brezina, CZE
Florent Amodio, FRA
Samuel Contesti, ITA
Takahiko Kozuka, JPN
Daisuke Murakami, JPN
Denis Ten, KAZ
Richard Dornbush, USA
Armin Mahbanoozadeh, USA
Douglas Razzanno, USA
Pairs:
Moore-Towers/Moscovitch, CAN
Zhang/Zhang, CHN
Hausch/Wende, GER
Savchenko/Szolkowy, GER
Bazarova/Larionov, RUS
Marley/Brubaker, USA
Vise/Baldwin, USA
Denney/Coughlin, USA
Dance:
Paul/Islam, CAN
Ralph/Hill, CAN
Pechalat/Bourzat, FRA
Zhiganshina/Gazsi, GER
Tobias/Stagniunas, LTU
Davis/White, USA
Hubbell/Donohoe, USA
Cannuscio/Lorello, USA

Skate Canada (Oct 28-30)
Ladies:
Amelie Lacoste, CAN
Cynthia Phaneuf, CAN
Adriana DeSanctis, CAN
Sarah Hecken, GER
Akiko Suzuki, JPN
Alena Leonova, RUS
Elizaveta Tuktamisheva, RUS
Rachael Flatt, USA
Mirai Nagasu, USA
Ashley Wagner, USA
Mens: 
Kevin Van Der Perren, BEL
Patrick Chan, CAN
Andrei Rogozine, CAN
Elladj Balde, CAN
Daisuke Takahashi, JPN
Denis Ten, KAZ
Javier Fernandez, ESP
Alexander Majorov, SWE
Ross Miner, USA
Adam Rippon, USA
Pairs:
Duhamel/Radford, CAN
Lawrence/Swiegers, CAN
Dube/Wolfe, CAN
Sui/Han, CHN
Yu/Jin, CHN
Takahashi/Tran, JPN
Iliushechkina/Maisuradze, RUS
Volosozhar/Trankov, RUS
Dance:
Virtue/Moir, CAN
Weaver/Poje, CAN
Harvey/Gagnon, CAN
Pechalat/Bourzat, FRA
Cappelini/Lanotte, ITA
Pushkash/Guerreiro, RUS
Riazanova/Tkachenko, RUS
Chock/Bates, USA
Cup of China (Nov 4-6)
Ladies:
Bingwa Geng, CHN
Kexin Zhang, CHN
Qiuying Zhu, CHN
Carolina Kostner, ITA
Valentina Marchei, ITA
Kanako Murakmi, JPN
Ksenia Makarova, RUS
Adelina Sotnikova, RUS
Christina Gao, USA
Mirai Nagasu, USA
Mens:
Kevin Reynolds, CAN
Jinlin Guan, CHN
Jialing Wu, CHN
Nan Song, CHN
Brian Joubert, FRA
Yuzuru Hanya, JPN
Nobunari Oda, JPN
Artur Gachinski, RUS
Jeremy Abbott, USA
Richard Dornbush, USA
Pairs:
Moore-Towers/Moscovitch, CAN
Steele/Schultz, CAN
Sui/Han, CHN
Zhang/Wang, CHN
Zhang/Zhang, CHN
Kadlecova/Bidar, CZE
Kavaguti/Smirnov, RUS
Evora/Ladwig, USA
Dance:
Yu/Wang, CHN
Huang/Zheng, CHN
Carron/Jones, FRA
Coomes/Buckland, GBR
Bobrova/Soloviev, RUS
TBD
Lichtman/Copely, USA
Shibutani/Shibutani, USA
NHK Trophy (Nov 11-13)
Ladies:
Cynthia Phaneuf, CAN
Kiira Korpi, FIN
Mae Berenice Meite, FRA
Elene Gedevanishvili, GEO
Mao Asada, JPN
Akiko Suzuki, JPN
Shoko Ishikawa, JPN
Alena Leonova, RUS
Ashley Wagner, USA
Agnes Zawadzki, USA
Mens: 
Tomas Verner, CZE
Samuel Contesti, ITA
Takahiko Kozuka, JPN
Daisuke Takahashi, JPN
Tatsuki Machida, JPN
Konstantin Menshov, RUS
Adrian Schultheiss, SWE
Armin Mahbanoozadeh, USA
Ross Miner, USA
Brandon Mroz, USA
Pairs:
Purich/Schultz, CAN
Savchenko/Szolkowy, GER
Berton/Hotarek, ITA
Takahashi/Tran, JPN
Iliushechkina/Maisuradze, RUS
Kavaguti/Smirnov, RUS
Castelli/Shnapir, USA
Denney/Coughlin, USA
Dance:
Paul/Islam, CAN
Weaver/Poje, CAN
Zhiganshina/Gazsi, GER
Alessandrini/Vaturi, ITA
Reed/Reed, JPN
Ilinykh/Katsalapov, RUS
Kriengkrairut/Giuletti-Schmitt, USA
Shibutani/Shibutani, USA

Trophee Eric Bompard (Nov 18-20)
Ladies:
Yrethe Silete, FRA
Lena Marrocco, FRA
Mae Berenic Meite, FRA
Sarah Hecken, GER
Carolina Kostner, ITA
Kanako Murakami, JPN
Elizaveta Tuktamisheva, RUS
Sonia LaFuente, USA
Victoria Helgesson, SWE
Alissa Czisny, USA
Mens:
Patrick Chan, CAN
Kevin Reynolds, CAN
Nan Song, CHN
Michal Brezina, CZE
Florent Amodio, FRA
Chaffik Besseghier, FRA
Brian Joubert, FRA
Nobunari Oda, JPN
TBD
Adam Rippon, USA
Pairs:
Duhamel/Radford, CAN
Dong/Wu, CHN
James/Cipres, FRA
Bazarova/Larionov, RUS
Stolbova/Klimov, RUS
Volosozhar/Trankov, RUS
Evora/Ladwig, USA
Dance:
Virtue/Moir, CAN
Huang/Zheng, CHN
Pechalat/Bourzat, FRA
Zahorski/Miart, FRA
Cappellini/Lanotte, ITA
Gorshkova/Butikov, RUS
Ilinykh/Katsalapov, RUS
Hurtado/Diaz, ESP

Rostelecom Cup (Dec 8-11)
Ladies:
Amelie Lacoste, CAN
Kiira Korpi, FIN
Mao Asada, JPN
Haruka Imai, JPN
Sofia Biryukova, RUS
Alena Leonova, RUS
Adelina Sotnikova, RUS
Rachael Flatt, USA
Christina Gao, USA
Agnes Zawadzki, USA
Mens: 
Andrei Rogozine, CAN
Michal Brezina, CZE
Tomas Verner, CZE
Yuzuru Hanyu, JPN
Artur Gachinski, RUS
Sergei Voronov, RUS
Konstantin Menshov, RUS
Javier Fernandez, ESP
Jeremy Abbott, USA
Brandon Mroz, USA
Pairs:
Jones/Gaskell, CAN
Hausch/Wende, GER
Savchenko/Szolkowy, GER
Berton/Hotarek, ITA
Gerboldt/Enbert, RUS
Kavaguti/Smirnov, RUS
Stolbova/Klimov, RUS
Cain/Reagan, USA
Dance:
Weaver/Poje, CAN
Carron/Jones, FRA
Reed/Reed, JPN
Tobias/Stagniunas, LTU
Bobrova/Soloviev, RUS
Riazanova/Tkachenko, RUS
Pushkash/Guerreiro, RUS
Davis/White, USA

Friday, June 24, 2011

My Favorite Seasons of Survivor In Order

As you may know from my tweets, I am an ultimate Survivor fan! I've watched every episode and know so much random trivia. I keep telling myself that I need to be on the show and I should just audition already. CBS, call me! I've been thinking a lot about my favorite Survivors (that will be another post) but for know I'm ranking my favorite seasons in order!

1) Survivor: All-Stars (Season 8)
All-Stars was by far my favorite seasons and I've watched it several times because all of my favorite Survivors came before and/or during that season. After the All-Star break, I think the contestants became more fake as they tried to replicate the performance of previous Survivors. I loved the three-tribe format of this season and the twist of Saboga being absorbed into Mogo-Mogo & Chapera when they kept losing challenges. The Rob & Amber romance was clearly the star of the season and Rob owned All-Stars (he should've won in my opinion) but there were just so many strong personalities that season. You had Richard Hatch, Rudy, Rupert, Big Tom, Sue Hawk, and Alicia as some of the more outspoken personalities. And then you had Kathy Obrien and Lex, two of my favorite strategic players of all time. Then there to top it off, you had my two favorite Survivor heartthrobs of any season, Colby and Ethan. All these ingredients together made for a phenomenal season.
2) Survivor: Borneo (Season 1)
You wouldn't be a true Survivor fan if you didn't love the original. Those first 16 castaways taught us the value of rice, boiling your water, and more importantly, the value of forming an alliance. Some amazing characters emerged from this season including the devious winner Richard Hatch, the tell-it-like-it-is Navy Seal Rudy Boesch, and "rat and snake speech" Sue Hawk. This season got me hooked and I haven't stopped watching since. Sure, players in later seasons may have been bolder and more colorful, but they owe it all to these guys. Richard Hatch is the original Survivor villain and he demonstrated just how important strategy is to the game.
3) Survivor: Pearl Islands (Season 7)
Pearl Islands may have had the loudest and most obnoxious contestants ever, but that makes great TV! The producers did an amazing job with this season and they followed the swashbuckling Pirate theme perfectly. From the first episode, I knew Sandra and Rupert were characters to watch. Sandra had such a mouth on her, and ironically that mouth and its ability to speak Spanish gave her tribe a huge head start as they were able to purchase a lot of valuable goods with the little money they had in a Panamanian village before being marooned on an island. Rupert, committing completely to the pirate theme, stole the Morgan tribe's shoes to trade for goods. This season also gave us the infamous Johnny Fairplay and the "dead Grandma" stunt that he pulled to win sympathy in his tribe. This season also employed an ultimate twist in allowing 2 early outcasts to return to the game. There were so many amazing things about this season and I could watch it over and over again, even if just for Sandra's one-liners. She is one of the handful of "true winners" in my opinion.
4) Survivor: Marquesas (Season 4)
This season yielded two All-Stars, but it in general it was more of a quirky season filled with random occurrences. Vecepia won this season by sliding under the radar and flipping sides so often that she barely knew where she was. Kathy O'Brien, one of my all time favorites was the clear winner of this season because of her outdoor skills, leadership, ability to think on her feet, and survival of a tribal swap that stacked the odds against her, but she was voted out and finished third because she was such a threat. Boston Rob was another favorite of this season and had he come out guns blazing rather than starting lazy, he could've won. Some hilights of the season were Kathy peeing on John's stingray-stung hand, the unraveling of the four-strong Rotu alliance, the father-daughter bond between Paschal and Neleh, and just about every racial comment that came out of Sean's mouth. Every time I rewatch this season I hate that Kathy doesn't win, but what can you do.
5) Survivor: The Australian Outback (Season 2)
The 2nd season of Survivor gave us a lot of important firsts. We got our first female villain, the "black widow" Jerri Manthey and our first Survivor hunk Colby Donaldson. This season also yielded more all-stars than any other. It was also the television debut of Elisabeth Filarski (Hasselbeck) who now co-hosts The View. We had the memorable fight over the chickens between Kimmy & Alicia as well as the great Mike Skupin who caught a pig and was later evacuated for falling into a fire, which is arguably the biggest turning point in Survivor history. If Mike had not been evacuated, the Kucha tribe would've likely gone into the merge with 6 members to Ogakor's 4, with the later being picked off, resulting in a much different final two that what actually happened with Colby & Tina. More importantly, Amber Brkich would probably wouldn't have made it as far, probably wouldn't have been chosen as an all-star, and wouldn't have met and aligned with Boston Rob Mariano and won all-stars. See what I mean by Skupin's exit changing the landscape of future Survivor seasons? This season also set the precedent for winners of the final immunity challenge selecting a weaker member to go with them to the final tribal council after Colby Donaldson lost the title of sole-survivor for selecting the likable Tina Wesson (the ultimate winner) for the final two over outcast Keith Famie.
6) Survivor: Heroes vs. Villains (Season 20)
This season was a great idea in theory, great survivors known for valiant moves vs. survivors know for devious moves. However, the casting was horrible and it was quite clear that the producers' first choices were not available so they had to complete the tribes with fill-ins. I mean Sugar, really? And Candice, what heroic move did she make in Cook Islands? I've also never been an Amanda fan and she did nothing deserving to be a hero in China or in Micronesia. On the Villains side the Rob vs. Russell dynamic was interesting, though Rob was voted out too soon for any real tension to develop. Parvati and Danielle were lapdogs to Russel while Courtney and Sandra flew under the radar. Coach was out in left field as usual and Jerri took a less aggressive role than in previous seasons and kept her comments to herself, resulting in her best finish of any of her three outings. The heroes had trouble in challenges and their biggest mistake, once they hit the merge, was ignoring Sandra's warnings and failing to vote out Russell, the kingpin on the Villains side. I love Sandra to death, but she was not as involved in orchestrating events in his season as she was in Pearl Islands and as much as I hate to say it, this was really Russel & Parvati's season.
7) Survivor: Amazon (Season 6)
This was the first season to feature a battle of the sexes with men on one tribe and women on the other which set up a very difference dynamic. It was an interesting social experiment and though the men worked extremely well together while the women bickered, they won basically the same number of challenges. This season had a few firsts, including the first deaf contestant, Christy, and the first naked contestants, Heidi and Jenna who took off their clothes in a challenge for chocolate and peanut butter.  This season really didn't get interesting until the merge when mastermind Rob Cesternino began to work his magic. He and runner-up Matthew were a great duo to watch because Matt had the survival and wilderness skills down pat while he needed Rob, an expert strategist and self-proclaimed student of the game to coach him in the social aspects. Jenna Morasca ultimately won by scrambling and winning the final immunity challenges. From an audience perspective, I found her to be an unlikable contestant but I am also aware that she was very young and grew up a lot from the experience and also that the producers edit to show viewers what they want them to see. I would have rather seen Rob in the final two, who played an expert strategic game, though he may not have garnered a lot of jury votes because he back-stabbed so many people, in which case the outdoorsy Matt would've been named the sole-Survivor.
8) Survivor: Africa (Season 3)
Survivor Africa only had one standout character, and that was goat farmer Big Tom, though it did have several amazing relationship dynamics. First we had the old vs. young rivalry on the Samburu tribe where the 20 somethings thought they could get by being lazy while the older members worked their tails off to maintain camp. We also had the epic Lex vs. Kelly when he went on a rampage to vote her off because he thought she had cast a vote against him when in fact he hadn't. This season gave us the first tribal switch where 3 members of each tribe were instructed to "go on a journey" which resulted in them becoming part of the opposing tribe until the merge. This ultimately allowed the original Boran tribe to make up the final four. Ethan Zohn was deserving, in my opinion, of the title of sole-Survivor for his perfectly balanced social, strategic, and physical games. He is one of the most likable Survivor winners to date. Of all seasons, this one still seems the most brutal. Their water source, a murky muddy creek, was the worst of any season and there was real danger nearby as they heard lions outside of their camp at night on many occasions. There was also the boredom aspect because they did not have the ocean or wooded areas that other seasons' contestants had to explore.
9) Survivor: Cook Islands (Season 13)
This season had a great opening twist where the tribes were divided by race. This pushed a lot of buttons and alienated a lot of advertisers, but they had to think of something new right? This season brought us some great characters and some shocking moments.Though she was boring overall, Candice was the first survivor ever to mutiny and the always abrasive Jonathan Penner followed suit. Parvati was a saucy minx who had a memorable hot tub moment with Ozzy and Yul and has become one of the best survivors ever to play the game. This season had perhaps the most deserving final two ever, Yul and Ozzy, as both were strong physical players who overcame huge odds. Yul went on to win as his social and strategic game overpowered Ozzy's more physical game.
10) Survivor: Guatemala (Season 11)
I loved Stephanie & Bobby Jon, the last two remaining members of the Ulong tribe in Palau, and I was happy to see them both return for a second shot at the million in Guatemala. Though neither were as likable as in Palau, some other great players emerged. This season had perhaps the toughest beginning ever as contestants were forced to hike for two days in sweltering heat, carrying all of their belongings and supplies, to make it to their camps. Though Bobby Jon came off as annoying and Stephanie as a backstabber, I grew to love other contestants, especially Rafe and Lydia for making the final four against big odds. This season didn't have a true villain and every single character was likable, at least most of the time. Danni Boatwright flew under the radar and won for her great social game, though she did do some great strategizing when her original tribe was down in numbers and her back was against the wall.
11) Survivor: Fans vs. Favorites (Season 16)
Jeff Probst has often said this was his favorite season, but I never loved these "favorites" as much as the original All-Stars. Sure Parvati was a great player but her act got old after a while and all Amanda did was whine. The "favorites" with the best TV personalities, Yau Man & Eliza were voted off too early so we got a whole lot of Parvati. The supposed "ultimate fans" were lame, though Erik did give us one of the most memorable Survivor moments ever when he was duped by the ladies into giving his immunity to Natalie, and ultimately voted out. I will give credit to those girls for dominating the game and to Parvati for leading one of the most notorious bands of women in Survivor history.
12) Survivor: Palau (Season 10)
Jeff Probst tauts this season as his favorite filming location and it was beautiful, though it was somber as well as Palau was very affected by WWII and some parts are still covered in wreckage. Like most seasons, this one began with a new twist. All 20 contestants were dropped off at one place and on day two the tribes divided themselves by a schoolyard pick. The two 2 contestants not selected were sent home immediately. The most memorable thing about this season was that the Ulong tribe never won immunity and when only one remained, Stephanie LaGrossa, she joined Koror and it became the only season without a true merge. Tom Westman was one of the most deserving winners ever as he dominated challenges, provided at camp (even catching a shark) and stuck by his original alliance of Ian and Katie to the very end. The only person who put up a fight against Tom was his ally Ian and when it came down to the final 5, Ian started to plot against Tom. But when Tom found out at the final 3, Ian chose to preserve his honor rather than win and gave final immunity to Tom. That was perhaps the most chivalrous moment in Survivor history, even if it was between two guys.
13) Survivor: Fiji (Season 14)
I hated this season's twist more than any other season because it was so incredibly unfair. All 19 contestants were dropped on the same beach and given materials and plans to build a fantastic structure. Then the tribes were split and the winners of the challenge got to keep the good camp while the others had to build a new shelter from no resources. This was basically "haves" (Moto) vs "have-nots" (Ravu) and it led to Moto dominated until the merge. We got some great characters and even better conflicts this season, particularly Yau Man Chan and Dreamz. One of the best Survivor moments ever was when Yau Man gave Dreamz the truck he won in a challenge in exchange for an immunity that would put him in the final 3. When Dreamz reneged, he made it to the final 3 but Earl Cole, who was seen as the best of the final 3, won unanimously. Earl was not the deserving winner as this was clearly Yau Man's season, as he dominated strategically and did very well in challenges given his age, but Earl was the clear choice of the top 3 over the lying, annoying Dreamz and the coattail-rider Cassandra.
14) Survivor: Samoa (Season 19)
Survivor fans thought they had seen it all until Russell Haantz came along in season 19. He was on a losing team that he sabotaged on occasion and managed to get himself and two of his original tribe-mates to the final 3. This guy did it all from burning tribe members socks to dumping canteens, all to cause commotion in the tribe and turn people against one another so they'd be easier to vote out. They once he made the merge, he became the first Survivor ever to find a hidden immunity idol without a clue. There were some other good characters this season like Shambo who turned on her own tribe because they belittled her in the beginning, but this was truly Russell's season. The only reason he didn't win was because his jury was filled with bitter babies who didn't understand that the point of the game is to Outwit, Outplay, Outlast. Instead Natalie, probably one of the least deserving winners ever, took home the million because she rode Russell's coat-tails and never had to truly backstab.
15) Survivor: China (Season 15)
The only twist to start this season was that the Survivors were only given the clothes on their back to start. The Fei Long tribe dominated early and went on to make up the final 4. This was a season of little people as Todd (the eventual winner) & Courtney (the runner up) dominated the social and strategic games though they lacked the strength to power through the physical challenges. Survivor China was themed excellently and is up there with Thailand and Pearl Islands in how well the producers and directors stayed true to the culture of the location in theming the challenges and rewards. James Clement, the gravedigger, emerged as an all-star player for his physical strength and blunt personality and went on to return in Fans vs. Favorites and Heroes vs. Villains. Amanda Kimmel (3rd place) also returned for those seasons though she was never as great on TV as James and came across as whiny. Conflicting personalities dominated the season, particularly Courtney vs. Jean-Robert and Dave vs. basically everyone on the Zhan Hu tribe. Todd was the clear mastermind of the season and used everyone in his path as a pawn in his plan, similarly to Rob Cesternino in The Amazon, but because Todd's social game was stronger, he was voted the sole Survivor and was deserving of that title.
16) Survivor: Panama (Season 12)
This season also had an opening twist as 16 contestants were split into 4 tribes by age and gender, but the main theme of the season was the introduction of Exile Island. Cirie Fields & Shane Powers emerged almost immediately as fan favorites for their tell-all personalities, and because they both felt out of place on the older tribes. This season was fairly boring early on but it heated up post-merge. Terry dominated the physical challenges but rubbed people the wrong way. Cirie played a great social & strategic game but hung on by a thread physically. Shane threatened to leave several times because due to withdraw from smoking and his son, but his crazy antics made for great TV. Danielle flew under the radar and clung to others, while Aras played a perfectly mixed game of the physical, strategic, and social. He was voted the ultimate Survivor over Danielle for getting to the end without making any real enemies, though Terry was bitter for being voted out in the final 3 and considered himself the ultimate player for his physical game.
17) Survivor: Tocantins (Season 18)
I remember very little about the challenges and the game itself this season, but I remember the personalities. If it weren't for the colorful Coach and Tyson and good old boy JT, this season would have completely sucked. Coach, who proclaimed himself the Dragon Slayer told one tall-tale after another about his grand adventures and escaping death, but while he annoyed his tribe mates, he was great for TV. Tyson was also a good character because with his dry, sarcastic sense of humor, you could never really tell when he was serious and when he was joking. JT was as sweet as can be but he cut throats when he needed to. He won challenges and made friends, garnering him a unanimous victory over the more intelligent Stephen in the final tribal council.
18) Survivor: Vanuatu (Season 9)
This is the season I'm currently re-watching but I really don't know why because it's not that good. It was a girl power season for sure and the guys sucked, though Chris manged to win so what do I know. Eliza was one of the great characters this season because she was so outspoken and was on the chopping block from from the first tribal council but made it the whole way to the final four. Scout and Twila, the older women, managed to play puppetmaster until the very end when Twila stabbed one too many people in the back and lost to the likable Chris in the final tribal council. Eliza is the only truly memorable character from this season and she returned in Fans vs. Favorites along with Ami. Eliza made it to the jury and her eye rolls every tribal council were priceless.
19) Survivor: Thailand (Season 5)
Jeff Probst has been very vocal that this is one of his least favorite seasons because it was mean-spirited and had the most unlikeable final four ever. I'll agree with both of those statements. This season was beautifully themed and had the most striking tribal council setup of any season but those were about the only positives. Almost everyone on this season was mean and Jake and Shii Ann were the only likable contestants. Unfortunately Shii Ann fell victim to the "fake merge" and was booted for attempting to flip to the other team, though we saw her again in All-Stars. Jake outlasted all of Sook Jai but Chuay Gahn stayed together to form the final five. Brian defeated clay 4-3 in the final tribal council though I hated them both so much I don't know how the jury chose. The one slightly redeeming quality this season was seeing an older, weaker tribe outlast the young cocky players, especially bully Robb Zbacnik.
20) Survivor: Redemption Island (Season 22)
For me, Survivor really went downhill after Heroes vs. Villains because its so hard to surprise an audience anymore, but this season introduced a very big new element. It is at the very heart of the game that contestants leave once voted out and this season producers shook it up by placing castoffs on Redemption Island for a shot at getting back in the game. Matt dominated Redemption Island, but it was finally Boston Rob's season. I think that fact that I knew he would win and deserved to win is what made this season so boring, despite Phillip's crazy antics.
21) Survivor: Nicaragua (Season 21)
This was the first season after Heroes vs. Villains so it was an automatic let down. Judd "Fabio" was a likable winner, but he kind of fell into a win by flying by the seat of his pants rather than actually deserving to win. He had some pretty exciting fights NaOnka though, who turned out to be one of the biggest bitches in Survivor history. This season the tribes were divided by ages so there was all kinds of clashing going on. Dallas Cowboys coach Jimmy Johnson was an early target because "he didn't need the money" though the older tribe suffered without his leadership. One of the best moments of the season was when Brenda got the boot after she and Sash paraded around as though they had the whole game under control. Boy was she surprised.
22) Survivor: Gabon (Season 17)
I hated this season from the very start. This may sound strange but the seasons filmed on dry land are always less exciting because water challenges are usually the highlight. This season featured a schoolyard pick and players played in the clothes they came in, both of which had been done before. The contestants this season really were a bunch of misfits and most of the athletic, competitive players were booted early. Pinup model Jessica "Sugar" Kiper spent a lot of time in the "Sugar Shack" aka exile island (which wasn't really an island) and Bob Crowley dominated. This season seemed to go on forever because there was so little to get excited about. The only thing that made it watchable was waiting for Bob to make more "fake" immunity idols.  

So You Think You Can Dance Recap: The Top 20 Results Show (again)!

I loved the opening number, it was very unique and I loved the simplicity of it. This is weird but I love when they truly dance as one and you can't pick out who is who. Dave Scott is great and I really want to see his work on the show more this season. Debbie Reynolds has loved the experience even though she "is used to being on the stage and has never been off the stage".

First 3 couples are: Missy/Wadi, Caitlynn/Mitchell, and Sasha/Alexander. Could Caitlynn be wearing any less clothes? Come on now let's keep it clean. Missy/Wadi are in the bottom 3 (we knew that) after that heinous Cha Cha. Caitlynn/Mitchell are safe (we knew that too) after that Stacey Tookey dullsville contemporary routine that was sure to be a crowd pleaser. Sasha/Alexander did the best routine of the night and if they are in the bottom 3 I'm not watching this show anymore. And they are safe too...which means I can keep blogging for y'all!

Gatorade is helping the dancers work on a nutrition programs which is a phenomenal idea. After the injuries last season, we need to keep these dancers as safe and healthy as possible.

Next 2 couples: Melanie/Marko and Miranda/Robert. Both sets are safe which was pretty much expected.

Next 2 couples: Jordan/Tadd and Iveta/Nick. Jordan/Tadd are safe so thank goodness America got it right and voted for a strong couple even though it wasn't necessarily a crowd-pleasing routine. Iveta/Nick are in the bottom 3 and Cat says she can't wait to see their solos. How weird is it that Iveta is nearly as tall as Cat?

Final 3 couples: Ashley/Chris, Ryan/Robert, and Clarice/Jess. This was the big surprise of the night because I really expected Clarice/Jess to be in the bottom after that mediocre contemporary number, but hey, whatcha gonna do. Ryan & Ricky will kill it in  the solos.

I always fast forward through the fluff on the results show...aka the dance crews and the musical "artists" that nobody has ever heard of.

Wadi didn't dance for his life like he meant it. He did what I've seen anybody do in the clubs, plus a lot of flares. Missy looked incredibly spastic and and whip her hair. Nick looked and sounded great just as expected. Goodness I hope they keep him! He's so cute and so good! It is so hard to do solos when you are a ballroom dancer. Iveta tried  but it looked like all she was really doing was shaking her ass. Ricky started out with a huge turn sequence and into a lot of other tricks, but he had some really interesting connecting movements and showed off some really spectacular ways of moving his body. He was truly dancing for his life. Ryan showed a ton of emotion in her solo but she was a little wild in her movements and lacked control.

I always hate how the judges bring each dancer forward and tell them how wonderful they are, blah, blah, blah. And the judges kept Ryan. She was so genuinely emotional. I think they picked her because she is such a diamond in the rough  and she hash so much potential for the rest of the season. Ricky's reaction was just as emotional and genuine as Ryan's! I'm genuinely sad to see Nick go, and even Wadi too! I'm pissed at Iveta for sucking in that Bollywood routine and putting Nick in the bottom 3.

Well that's it for me guys. Next week's guest judge is my girl Kristin Chenoweth! Until next Wednesday's live-blog, Peace Out!

Thursday, June 23, 2011

So You Think You Can Dance Recap: The Top 20 Perform (again)!

Because Nigel was feeling nice last week and didn't cut any dancers, the top 20 performed once again. Maybe it was because most of the dancers had to step out of their style or maybe because the choreography was bland, but overall I was unimpressed with last night's episode. Here is my live play-by-play of the episode in case you missed it http://backstagebarbie.blogspot.com/2011/06/so-you-think-you-can-dance-top-20.html

Here are my favorite routines in order...

1) Sasha & Alexander Lyrical Hip Hop: Thank the Lord, Napoleon & Tabitha have returned! They are masters of this style and nobody does it like them, in my opinion. This piece about a soldier returning home from war to his emotionally tormented wife was poignant, particularly after the President's announcement before the the show about withdrawing troops in 2012. Many thought Sasha was too aggressive and too hard-hitting, but I really think that was a character choice and it showed that her husband's absence left her feeling tortured from the inside-out. Alex looked a little dead-faced like he did last week and he really needs to up his performance level to meet Sasha's. They should be 100% safe tonight.

2) Jordan & Tadd Viennese Waltz: I cannot even believe I'm picking a ballroom style as my 2nd favorite but it was just a huge surprise for me how well they did. I mean Tadd is a b-boy, all he does is freestyle, and I was shocked to see how incredible his posture and body carriage was. He looked so elegant and he was there for his partner. He even had the proper rise and fall. Jordan was fine, but Tadd definitely pulled focus. She had a little too much sass and not quite enough polish in my opinion. Wardrobe also did a poor job with her, putting her in a costume that made her look stocky when in fact she is not. They should be safe tonight.

3) Miranda & Robert Hip Hop: I was just so excited for the return of Tabitha & Napoleon last night! I love their choreography, but even more, I love that they are constantly coming up with new concepts. I could be wrong, but it always seems like they come up with their themes and then find music to fit, rather than letting the music and lyrics dictate the movement. I mean a daddy and a baby woodpecker? You can't get much more out of the box than that. This is Robert's style, but Miranda did her best to keep up and showed her grit when she got back up after eating it on a flip. I'd have them as safe, but they could potentially be in danger.

4) Caitlynn & Mitchell Conemporary: I hate that Stacey Tookey can't come up with anything but love stories or love stories gone wrong for her contemporary routines, but I'm ranking this routine high simply for its  movement quality. I've decided that I'm no longer going to expect great concepts from Stacey. I'm going to look at her routines strictly as movement for movement's sake. Caitlynn & Mitchell are a fantastic pair and it was great to see them dance together. They have great lines, extension and lift in jumps and leaps. The movement was gorgeous and flowed well with the music but the concept was tacky and so was that stupid lamp on stage. The chairs would have sufficed.

5) Melanie & Marko Jazz: This routine should have been great on paper but in no way shape or form should Sing Sing Sing ever be updated. Mandy Moore could have played with putting contemporary movement to a classic song  without actually choosing a techno version. Melanie & Marko did a great job with the intricate choreography and they looked quite polished. I didn't even see the moment when Marko dropped the hat. The one thing that bugged me about the piece was that we could tell right away when a jump or lift was coming because of the big preparation. I think they should be safe tonight, not only because it was a solid routine, but also because of the huge response to their statue routine last week.

6) Ryan & Ricky Jazz: I love these two and it was hard for me to be critical of the routine but it just was not good enough. There were issues in ever way possible from the stale choreography and 80s-tacular song choice to the costume malfunctions. One thing I also noticed last night is that Ryan & Ricky are nearly the same height which can be awkward visually. We'll see how that works when they draw their first ballroom routine. Another thing I noticed is that Ryan, though she makes up for it in heart, lacks a bit of polish. She is a little clunky and heavy in her movements and hasn't yet mastered how to use her long limbs to her advantage. I hate to admit it but they may be in danger tonight

7) Iveta & Nick Bollywood: I grew to love Nick even more in this routine because of his dedication and commitment. He was 150% into the routine and his energy made us all believe that he actually knew what he was doing. He keeps tweeting that his dream is to dance with Allison Holker and he seems dead set on making the top 10. Iveta on the other hand, brought the routine down with her lack of energy and commitment. She was half a beat behind Nick the entire routine and never finished her movements or extended her limbs. Mary proclaimed her the Queen of the ballroom, which may be true, but in something outside of her own style she just looked uninterested. I give Nick an A for effort but I don't know that my goodwill alone can keep them safe tonight.

8) Ashley & Chris Broadway: I get where  Spencer Liff was going with this and I do praise him for creativity, but it was much much too literal. I think this may have worked as a jazz or contemporary piece with a song about longing or being kept apart, but using Cry Baby's "please Mr Jailer" took away all the suspense and drama. It was danced well enough but the bars limited the choreography. It was more posing and doing tricks on the bars than actual full-bodied movement. I think that it was sassy and flashy enough that they'll probably be safe tonight.

9) Clarice & Jess Contemporary: This piece was blah blah blah for me. I'll give Stacey Tookey credit for coming up with a stronger theme (Prince & Princess) in this piece but if they hadn't been in those costumes, I would have had no idea that was the concept because nothing in the music or movement backed it up. They really struggled with the lifts, which surprises me because Jess has been on Broadway 3 times and he should know how to partner. I think a lot of it may be his ego and Clarice is suffering because of it. As Nigel said, they did a phenomenal routine last week that put them in the bottom 3 so after this mediocre showing, I assume they'll be there again.

10) Missy & Wadi Cha Cha: This routine was just all kinds of wrong. A) Jean-Marc said upfront that this was the hardest routine he's ever done for the show. Why then would he use it for week 2 and with  non-ballroom dancers? B) The song was annoying and obnoxious. C) Wadi tried but his upper body was so weak and he seemed to be behind Missy the whole time. D) Missy's "come hither" faces were so unnecessary. You can do that if the routine is flawless but when its not, well then that's just tacky. I'm not picking on them but if they don't end up in the bottom 3, then something is wrong.

Wednesday, June 22, 2011

So You Think You Can Dance: The Top 20 Perform (again)!

Here we are again on a Wednesday evening around 8pm EST watching the top 20 perform on FOX's So You Think You Can Dance. Deja vu much? Nigel, being the softie that he is, decided to keep all the dancers last week, which means that we'll see 2 couples go tomorrow night. That's 4, count 'em 4 dancers! This is a big week for the performers as there is such little margin for error. Last week nearly every dancer or couple drew their own style so expect to see some switch-ups tonight. Hip-hoppers doing ballroom anyone? Either way, get ready for some good choreography, some great technique, and some even better Mary Murphy outbursts because this.....is So You Think You Can Dance...according to Barbie of course.

10:10 Well all thats it for me tonight. I'm going to analyze my thoughts and write a recap tomorrow where I'll also try to predict the bottom three. Until then, happy dancing!
10:08 Mary nobody cares about your Hot Tamale train dear. I really hope that Debbie took out her hearing aide before that signature Mary squeal
10:06 Obviously a side tilt is necessary when we are doing a piece about prison. Anytime I visit someone in prison, I always do a side-tilt.
10:04 Spencer dear I get that bars have never been used on the show, but that doesn't necessarily mean that its a good idea
9:57 The judges love it and I agree. Tabitha & Napoleon are fantastic storytellers!
9:56 Get it together Mary, big girls don't cry!
9:53 This is a perfect song for this story. That moment of connection was just phenomenal. That was certainly the WOW dance of the night.
9:52 I can tell from rehearsal that this is going to be a memorable piece.
9:46 I want some of whatever Debbie Reynolds is on, pretty please!
9:43 "Sing Sing Sing" I'd say that is an oldie but a goodie. I love the intricacy and musicality of the piece and Melanie has great leg lines for a short girl. I kind of hate this remix. Melanie has a great layout. The split catch lift was good, but I hate how we totally knew when it was coming.
9:42 Let's hope this Mandy Moore choreography is better than the last one
9:41 I love that all dancers are so immature and silly...not just me.
9:35 Mary I wouldn't go announcing "the surprise of the season" yet in week 2. Also, that dress is not flattering on Jordan. It gives her love handles that she probably doesn't have.
9:34 I don't agree that Jordan is so beautiful and elegant, but Tadd was really phenomenal.
9:32 Very nice penchay from Jordan and some pretty nice upper body carriage from Tadd. Okay so I scoffed at this but Tadd is actually pretty good. The woman is supposed to be the picture while the man is the frame, but I'm only watching Tadd.
9:31 Is Jordan wearing a curtain as a skirt?
9:30 Wow so Jordan really is our slow friend. Tadd is OCD.
9:23 Okay I get it, Stacey Tookey is jonesing for some media attention from the royal couple. I agree with Nigel that the separate movement was nice but the partnering lacked fluidity
9:21 If she wanted this to be really unique, she should have gone with a Disney song or something and made it into a parody. Other than the costuming, nothing in this piece tells me that he is a prince and she is a princess.The side by side movement is nice, it has some really great bounce to it. Was it just my viewpoint or did Jess botch that turn?
9:20 What the what Stacey Tookey? You did another love story on the same show? This is so un-called for. Like I get that the "prince-princess" thing is different but really?
9:19 Is Clarice's secret that she can do a leg catch turn?
9:13 Nigel has about the worst set of dentures that I've ever seen
9:12 So Debbie Reynolds just did a Woody the Woodpecker impression, #Idie
9:10 Robert looks really good, and he uses those long limbs in such an interesting way, but Miranda doesn't seem completely committed to the movement. She seems to be marking the routine. Newsflash girlfriend, you are on the BIG stage. The ending with the dive offstage was precious
9:09 Now this is an interesting concept that is not, I repeat NOT a love story
9:08 Miranda has a crush on Tadd, which is so precious (and juicy)
9:02 I'm 98% sure that Debbie Reynolds is either drunk or on some REALLY good meds
9:01 Mary, I get that you have a girl crush on Iveta, but she did NOT shine on that stage. She couldn't have been less interested if she had been giving waltz lessons at a nursing home.
9:00 Nigel, Joshua & Katie were 4 seasons ago, so like why bring them up?
8:58 The lighting is very nice in this piece. I feel like Nick is killing it but Iveta is lagging behind and is not straightening her arms and/or fully hitting all of the movements. Good energy overall from Nick but Iveta was lacking
8:57 Dancers always give the same response when then find out the have bollywood, always a dazed and confused look
8:56 Iveta talks to herself in mirrors & Nick always wears shorts; this whole "get to know your partner" segment makes for such bad TV
8:50 Mary is praising Missy as the "cha cha Queen".....okay whatever Mary. And Debbie "cougar" Reynolds just offered to take Wadi home and cha-cha with him anytime
8:49 Nigel just said, imma keep it real. And he basically told Wadi he had a lot of work to do and that was very true. Nigel praised Missy, but like if you are an expert jazz dancer, cha-cha isn't so so far away
8:48 Those poor dears, good try but that was heinous
8:47 Wow this is just horrible from the technique and the execution to the song and the "come get me faces."
8:46 Why would Jean Marc do his most difficult routine ever in week 2? Why, God Why?
8:38 "Dance is the language of the soul" -Nigel Lythgoe. Who wants to knit that on a sampler? Needlepoint anyone?
8:37 Thank GOD Debbie started singing! I just love that broad!
8:36 The judges are so nice this season. What is this, American Idol?
8:35 It was a very visually appealing piece (minus the lamp) but we've seen all of that movement and all of that emotion before.
8:34 I love an Adele moment, but can we say 'overused'? I like how we don't see Caitlynn's face for that opening section. Also, why do we need this lamp? That is just so unnecessary. This is not a Broadway set.
8:33 Get it Stacey Tookey in your booty shorts and oversized V-neck! I hate that ever partner dance is a "love story" or a "love story gone wrong". There is soooo much more to dance about!
8:32 This whole "partner secret" thing is so tacky. And why is Caitlynn giggling like a 12-year old at a middle school dance?
8:30 Wait so why was I so nice about that routine? Mandy is doing the same choreo she did circa 1997 and Ryan dear, why couldn't you stick that double pirouette?
8:26 And what does the dame thing? Debbie "never saw anyone dance sexier". She fell out of her top and he fell out of his bottom, and they gave her their all. Hahahaha Debbie I love it!
8:25 What on earth is Mary wearing? Something resembling an epaulette? She loves Ryan's strength and Ricky's character
8:25 Nigel is acting as if jazz is a huge step away from contemporary, which it isn't in my mind, ps he called them raunchy
8:24 I love the dancers and the choreography, but this routine isn't really going anywhere conceptually. But I think that is ok, it was a good dance just for dance's sake
8:23 I love when Mandy goes to an 80s-tacular place; Ricky looks sexy but Ryan looks a little awkward and clunky. She is one of those dancers who has such long limbs but hasn't completely mastered how to use them
8:23 Ryan and Ricky are such goofballs and Mandy Moore clearly is not having any of that; they need to kick up the performance level
8:22 Oh wow I didn't realize that they were keeping the same partners all season
8:20 Doesn't that old clip just take you back!
8:19 Debbie Reynolds is such a grand Dame! I just love that gal!
8:16 Its so cute that we saw the dancers enter in their pairs from last year
8:15 And after the Presidential address, we are FINALLY starting (thanks to FOX for showing the entire episode)


Friday, June 17, 2011

A Toast To That Invincible Bunch: My Review of Company

Please dont' think it blasphemous when I say that Company is not my favorite Sondheim musical because I found the New York Philharmonic's production, which I saw in a humble movie theatre, to be impeccably done. It is technically a "staged concert," though my only previous experience with the show is the 2006 Broadway production directed by John Doyle in minimalist fashion. Because this show centers around everyday upper-middle class white folk, the simple staging suits it best. I know this phrase is tossed around a lot, even by me, but I really look at Company as "a play with music." There aren't too many showstoppers or flashy dance breaks, but the book and the story really shine. We open with bachelor Bobby's (Neil Patrick Harris) friends hiding in his apartment to surprise him for his 35th birthday. The play is not linear; it uses a series of vignettes to show Bobby's exploration of marriage through the lens of his married friends and three girlfriends.

Neil Patrick Harris is not the egotistical, set-in-his-ways Bobby seen in many productions, but rather he seems genuinely open to considering marriage. Throughout the play Bobby visits four couples where he learns important lessons about marriage, almost as if he were Ebeneezer Scrooge but without the ghosts. The first couple we are introduced to is Sarah (Martha Plimpton) & Harry (Stephen Colbert) who are both "on the wagon". They bicker about how long they'be been free from their addictions, his to alcohol and hers to food, while Bobby tries to intervene and assuage the situation. Colbert is a classic example of why Sondheim is for actors who sing rather than singers who act. He may not be a songbird, but comic timing, well that he has down pat. He and Plimpton have a kinetic chemistry that radiates from the silver screen, particularly when their witty repartee escalates into a hilarious karate match. Despite their fighting, they look forward to sleeping next to one another, which is Bobby's first lesson about marriage.

Susan (Jill Paice) & Peter (Craig Bierko) are the Southern Belle-Ivy League power couple and both actors do a fine job with relatively small parts. Susan is so charming that Bobby "wants to be the first to know when Peter leaves her". To his surprise they tell him they are divorcing. For Bobby, their divorce makes him even more cynical about marriage. Though Bobby is more of an observer and rarely comments on the marital problems of his friends, it is easy to see that Harris' wheels are always turning. He is taking stock of his friends though he cannot yet process what he's seen.

Next we meet Jenny (Jennifer Laura Thompson) and David (Jon Cryer) as they are lighting a joint with Bobby. Thompson is a very giddy Jenny, reminiscent of what she did with Glinda in Wicked, and Cryer is spot on as the very dry David. Jenny is uber-conservative and never swears, but when she is high, David takes great joy in hearing her repeat his obscenities. Bobby finds this charming, especially when David tells him that Jenny doesn't really enjoy pot, but she does it to please him.

You Could Drive A Person Crazy,  one of the more hum-able numbers from the show is a trio performed by Bobby's girlfriends Marta (Anika Noni Rose), April (Christina Hendricks), and Kathy (Chrissie Whitehead) as they discuss his skittish and noncommittal ways. He is their "hobby" and they're "giving  him up". The choreography is simple, but Whitehead stands out as the one with the most formal dance training and leaves the other two in the dust. Though Rose and Hendricks make up for the lack of dance technique in acting and presence, this number could've used more rehearsal. Rose's Marta is the standout among the three overall and her Another Hundred People is a highlight of the show. When she speaks of her love for the city and its energy I truly felt it, even in the movie theatre.

The act ends with Amy (Katie Finneran) & Paul (Aaron Lazar) on their wedding day. Amy has cold feet and can't stand the thought of being faithful to one man for the rest of her life. Amy is one of those roles that can be so tacky with the wrong actress but it is in good hands with Finneran and her Not Getting Married Today  is the best I've ever heard. Harris makes it quite clear that Bobby has feelings for Amy and he all but encourages her to call off the marriage. This is a cruel realization that Amy is off the market as she decides to marry Paul.

Act II kicks off back at Bobby's party and he blows out the candles followed by Side by Side, a song and dance number where he and all his friends sing about the joys of partnership. The choreography is based on call and response between the two-somes and it is a rude awakening for Bobby when he has nobody to finish his steps.

Hendricks' April relies heavily on flighty-ness and though its cute at the beginning, it slows the pace and by the end of Barcelona, you feel you've been watching the same scene for an hour. Things pick up when Bobby takes Marta to visit newly divorced Susan & Peter who are still living together. She is so excited by the prospect of a live-in divorce and adds that to the list of things she loves about New York City.

The penultimate scene is the show, features everyone's favorite number, The Ladies Who Lunch performed by Patti LuPone as Joanne. In between toasting her first and second husbands, she takes time to recognize that special class of women who "lounge in their caftans planning a brunch on their own behalf." LuPone can command any stage large or small and this is a perfect diva role for her. She puts her own spin on this number that is so closely connected with Elaine Stritch. She really takes her time and each lyric is crystal clear. She approaches it more as a scene than a song and its much more about diction and pacing than pitch and vibrato. She has the tall order of playing two roles: the real Joanne that her husband Larry (Jim Walton) is privy to and the more brassy abrasive Joanne that the rest of the world sees. She does each one impeccably well and the shift in her eyes when Larry tells Bobby that he hopes he can meet the real Joanne one day is a thing of beauty.

The final scene leaves Bobby very confused and Harris seems quite pained as he thinks of everything bad that there is about marriage. "Someone to hold you too close, someone to hurt you too deep, someone to sit in your chair and ruin your sleep." His friends coax him from afar to realize that all of this elements of relationships that he perceives to be negative are just simple reminders that he is alive, something that he has been alone too long to remember. This transitions seamlessly to Being Alive, the emotional heart of the show. Sondheim is a master of the 11 o'clock number. Almost all of his shows feature an emotional catharsis where the protagonist learns a (sometimes hard to stomach) lesson. In Sunday in the Park With George, its Move On and in Into The Woods its Children Will Listen. Its the same as Losing My Mind in Follies  and Send In The Clowns in A Little Night Music.

We never really know what happens to Bobby but back in his apartment his friends leave, thinking he has forgotten about his party, and he reemerges to sit in his chair and grin before the lights go out. A pessimist may think that Bobby has pulled the wool over his friends' eyes and decided to remain alone even after they've shown him the "joys" of marriage. But I like to think that Bobby has finally grown up and realized that he can't make it on his own.

So You Think You Can Dance Recap: Top 20 Results Show

So the opening number was bondage themed. What is Fox trying to sell anyway? The movement was very unique and all I could think about was how amazing Mark Kanemura would look in that movement. Sonya Tayeh is the it girl of contemporary and jazz right now and her movement is always interesting and she never recycles her work.

I just love Megan as a judge on the show and I wish they'd keep her around. Hopefully we'll see her again soon! Nigel spoke a lot about national dance die, Cat went on and on about the special performance, blah blah blah. Let's get to the results!

First up were Melanie & Marko and duh they were safe. Missy & Wadi did the Sean Cheeseman Pandora's box jazz routine that I hated...and before we give them their results we had to review Iveta & Nick's quickstep. Both were safe. I disagree because I would've put Missy & Wadi in the bottom, but then again what do I know? I've only been in this business for 20 years.

The next group included Ashley & Chris who had the misfortune of doing that heinous Chris Scott hip hop routine that had no originality and no difficult. We also saw Jordan & Tadd  who did the better of the two Sean Cheeseman routines last night, the afro jazz. And Jordan & Tadd go to the bottom 3 while Ashley & Chris are safe? What was America thinking?? Then poor Caitlynn had to stand there along onstage as her "partner" Mitchell already has to dance for his life. She is safe. And then Clarice & Jess fell to the bottom 3? They did that stunning nuanced Broadway piece but all that did was prove that America likes tricks rather than legit dancing.

Then because of the beauty of tivo I could fast forward through that heinous Kerry Hillson routine.

Ryan & Ricky were up next. Ryan is my girl and they were safe!! Sasha & Alexander were also in this group along with Miranda & Robert. Miranda & Robert to to the bottom 3 while Sasha & Alexander were safe.

Russian dancers have springs in their feet. The Gopak number proved that indeed white men can jump!

Its solo time so get prepared for the tricks! First up we have Mitchell who was injured last night. Doing such an overdone song as Say by John Mayer is not a good idea. Doing such a long devellope was not a good use of his time to dance for his life.

Jordan knows how to work it and show everything she needs to in that short period. That is how you dance for your life and she brought her signature sex appeal.

Tadd comes out breaking to Jump Jive and Wail  which is such a quirky combo and shows his personality and sense of humor in addition to his technical skills. The judges loved it.

Clarice is all about the legs and the hair but she doesn't really who much in the solo other that grande battements and whipping her hair back and forth. She also botched her a la seconde turns which is a huge no no on this show.

Jess came out in a bowler hat and showed of his technical prowess with a very controlled pirouette. He stays true to his style and shows us a great mixture of personality, showmanship and technique.

Miranda comes out swinging and I loved her pirouette arch into layback. She definitely could be more controlled and she showed signs of nerves. She wasn't as clean as some other girls but I think she showed a lot of fight.

Robert didn't show much actually training for me. Everything he did was something I've seen in clubs.

If it were up to me, I would send Robert and Clarice home but who knows what these judges will do.

I loved how Cat thought she was "breaking" the news of Gaga guest judging when I actually heard that a few days ago.

And after deliberations and feelings from the judges.....they asked two of the boys to dance again. Why is this necessary? Oh yeah, its not.

Oh lord and we kept everyone. I am all for giving people second chances, but the name of the game is choosing America's favorite dancer so how are we going to get down to one if we keep them all? So to wrap it up, we didn't eliminate anybody in the elimination show but we are cutting two couples next week. That's it for me guys. Until next Wednesday, Peace Out!

Thursday, June 16, 2011

So You Think You Can Dance Recap: The Top 20 Perform!

For my live play-by-play of last night's episode you can click this link http://backstagebarbie.blogspot.com/2011/06/so-you-think-you-can-dance-june-15th.html
Here are my favorite performance from last night in order.

1) Melanie & Marko Contemporary: I am very critical of Travis Wall's choreography normally but I have to give credit where credit is due and this was an extraordinary piece of art. The statue theme will be memorable for seasons to come and it was beautifully danced to boot.

2) Clarice & Jess Broadway: I've always loved Tyce Diorio's Broadway pieces and this Me & My Baby number was another great one. Jess has three Broadway credits and he was darn near perfect. Clarice didn't quite rise to his level and missed some of the nuances and precision that Jess nailed, but it was a solid and entertaining routine nonetheless. They should be safe tonight.

3) Ryan & Ricky Lyrial Hip Hop: I love this style, though Chris Scott doesn't hold a candle to NappyTabs. I have loved Ryan since last season when she was cut last minute and these two had amazing chemistry. The judges criticized her for smiling too much but when she explained the concept to the judges they understood her motives. If the dancer has to explain a concept to the judges then that is a discredit to the choreographer. These are all-star choreographers and they should be able to clearly communicate their message through their dancers. I think these two will be audience favorites and shouldn't be in any danger tonight.

4) Iveta & Nick Quickstep: I cannot believe I'm putting a Quickstep in my top four routines but this was great. Iveta is a world champion in this dance so I wasn't worried about her but Nick truly rose to her level. Though he had to learn the ballroom posture, he is a tapper so the footwork came pretty naturally to him. They were well suited as partners and choreographer Jason Gilkerson chose a great song, Ballroom Blitz, to make it as exciting as possible. Though I thought it was a solid routine, I predict America will put it in the bottom 3 but as long as they don't blow their solos, I'm almost positive the judges will save these two. 

5) Sasha & Alexander Contemporary: This was one of those Travis Wall pieces I didn't like because it was about a broken relationship like most of his work. This piece showed Sasha off beautifully and she is just so strong....like a dancing Xena. Her emotion was spot on but Alexander looked vacant, though her body lines were stunning. His dancing is great, but he needs to work more on connecting his body and his face. This routine should leave them safe after the results are read.

6) Jordan & Tadd Afro Jazz: I like this piece because it was aggressive and it gave the dancers a chance to show just how much they want to be there because they had to truly commit to the movement to do it properly. This proved that Jordan & Tadd are tough dancers and you can throw anything at them. This high-energy piece was likely an audience pleaser and they should be safe.

7) Melissa & Wadi Jazz: I did not like the choreography of this Sean Cheeseman jazz piece because there wasn't any choreography. It was a lot of leg tricks from Melissa & b-boy stunts from Wadi masquerading as a dance. Sean's "pandora's box of sexy demons" theme was just tacky and much too elaborate to develop properly in such a short routine. I would personally put this in the bottom 3 but I'm assuming that it probably got a lot of votes from America because it was flashy and showy.

8) Caitlynn & Mitchell (Robert): Mitchell was unfortunately injured this week and last season's Robert had to stand in for him. This was rather unfortunate for Caitlynn as she seemed to struggle next to Robert, especially because he does Sonya's work so well. She doesn't yet have his polish or precision but she had great energy and performance. Mitchell is automatically in the bottom 3 so it will be interesting to see what happens to Caitlynn.

9) Miranda & Robert Jive: These dancers were victims of situation because they were one of the few pairs who didnt' draw their own style. They did their best and the energy was good but they struggled with unison and with the intricacies of the footwork and leg placement. I suspect this will put them in the bottom 3.

10) Ashley & Chris Hip Hop: I do not like what I've seen so far of Christopher Scott's work and I think his concepts are trite & underdeveloped. This piece explored the overused theme of "cheating" and the comedic aspect made it seem silly. The choreography was so elementary and did not show off what the dancers are capable of. This piece should be in the bottom 3, though it is not the fault of the dancers. They were victims of poor material.


Wednesday, June 15, 2011

So You Think You Can Dance: June 15th Liveblog

Welcome to my first So You Think You Can Dance Liveblog of season 8! I'll be doing this every Wednesday for the rest of the season. Tonight we'll see the top 20 pair up to perform 10 exciting original routines. I can't wait!

9:56 That's a wrap for tonight guys. I  won't be with you live for tomorrow night's show, but I will post a recap later in the evening after I watch the show. I'll be liveblogging again next Wednesday for the top 18 episode. Until then, happy dancing!
9:53 According to Nigel, Nick conquered the Quickstep, the dance of death, because of his fabulous tap dancing feet. I always love Jason Gilkerson's choreography and he does a great job of making the routines entertaining so that ballroom appeals to the TV audience.
9:51 Ballroom Blitz is a very fun song for a quickstep. Nick is looking pretty good on the first run across the stage! He is also performing the heck out of it as is she. This his pretty exciting for a quickstep if I must say.
9:50 I love how Yveta acts like she is the instructor.
9:49 I forgot that Oksana Baiul was on this show! Oh wait, that's Yvetta and she is partnering with Nick the tap dancer. Let's hope his quick footwork helps him in the quickstep!
9:44 Megan gives a big shout out to the costume, hair, and makeup team and calls them the best on TV.
9:43 I hated that choreography so much but I can't fault the dancers for the choreographer's work.
9:41 This song is comical and it fits Christopher's "theme". This movement is so elementary and I get that it's intended to be humorous, but it really looks silly.
9:40 Choreographers......can we PLEASE develop some concepts that don't involve love stories or cheating? There is so much other material to explore.
9:39 What I want to know is if they are all really that excited to see their partners. A Hip Hop routine by Christopher Scott by Chris & Ashley.
9:32 Standing O from the judges! Mary gets emotional. I agree with Mary & Megan that the piece was truly special and magical. Also, love Travis's sparkly suit. I usually don't love Travis' choreography but this really was a special one.
9:29 From the first movements I can tell that this will be one of the top routines of the season. Melanie has such amazing control of her limbs and Marko is such a strong individual and partner for her. The emotion is spot-on. This is a good example of it being totally appropriate to do leg-tricks because it fits the theme of the piece. This was just phenomenal. They are the team to beat!
9:28 Congratulations Travis Wall for developing an interesting concept! Coincidence that they are both contemporary dancers and they drew that style.
9:27 I love Melanie! She is so fresh-faced and innocent-looking and just lovely overall. And I love Marko! He is so real!
9:22 Megan consistently has the most sensible and constructive commentary for each piece.
9:20 Nigel is correct in saying that this year's hip-hoppers are adapting remarkably well to other styles.
9:18 I like the manipulation of the box set pieces. The could be cleaner. At one point she was expecting him to lift her and had to look back to find him. There are so many tricks in this piece. The actual dancing is really great but is so sparse. I did not like this choreography. I think Shawn is a little full of himself in thinking that those evolved concepts can actually come to fruition.
9:17 The concepts behind the pieces are very elaborate this week. We are doing a sexy evil demon Pandora's box jazz dance. I'm sorry but Miss Clarissa didn't teach me that in class.
9:16 Missy & Wadi doing doing jazz. Sooooo much jazz on this show.
9:09 In all these years of hosting SYTYCD, Cat still doesn't know what a pony is?
9:08 Megan comments on the energy and fun of the piece. She calls Miranda "goofy" but announces her love to Robert.
9:07 That was an unfortunate draw for style for them and I think that may be a bottom-three routine.
9:06 They have great bounce to them, a real spring to their step and a lot of power in the kicks. This lighting is serving them well as the flashes disguise some of the incorrect technique on the kicks and flicks. She keeps looking back at him in a way that looks like she needs to see him to remember the choreography.
9:05 So they drew "latin" but its jive? Does that mean the choreographer can pick the style when they get the dancers? Why is she wearing silver lame boots?
9: 04 Yeah Miranda repp-ing Pittsburgh! I also love her big hair. She is a contemporary dancer partnering a hip hop dancer in a Jive? Should be interesting.
8:58 Nigel gives her "10s across the board". I don't agree but such is life.
8:57 Mary: "Every girl wants to be you". Really Mary? I wouldn't really call Caitlynn phenomenal yet but she is really showing potential and she did have the disadvantage of performing with a "potential" all-stars.
8:56 Unfortunately for Caitlynn, Robert is so fantastic that he made her look inexperienced. She seemed to be playing catch up to stay with Robert.
8:55 Sonya's work requires such abandon which I love. They are recklessly in control in this piece. They really hit the syncopation and this piece is choreographed wonderfully for the accents.
8:54 Here we have Caitlynn dancing with Robert (love) from season 7. I love La Roux but this is my first time hearing this song (in for the kill).
8:53 So Caitlynn is dancing with Mitchell (who is injured) in a jazz routine by Sonya. Now that Mitchell is injured, I wonder who she'll dance with. (Mitchell is sweaty & slippery btw).
8:46 Megan has to wonder what she got herself into sitting next to that nutso Mary Murphy. I love that she mentioned the term "through-line". She is such a professional.
8:45 Mary you can't tell every dancer that they were the most talented girl or guy of the season. When you hand out compliments so easily, they lose their weight.
8:44 Nigel, you are always the biggest culprit of this, but I hate when you give the dancers criticism based on the choreography, which is completely out of their control.
8:43 This was not up there (in choreography or performance) with the great NappyTabs lyrical hip hop routines, but it was a good start. I don't know that they connected enough emotionally for the physical anger in the piece.
8:42 I like the sharp syncopation of the opening sequence. Using a classic song like Aint No Sunshine is so inventive for a hip hop routine. I don't like the lighting of this piece because it is hard to see their facial expressions, though the bodies are really showing a great deal of emotion.
8:41 It looks like the acting part of this won't be hard. They seem to genuinely like each other.
8:40 love Ryan Ramirez and I want to see her go the whole way. She is partnering with fellow contemporary dancer contemporary to do a Chris Scott lyrical hip hop routine. (I love that they are both wearing flannel....its so in for dancers now lol)
8:35 Mary basically tells Jess he gave as perfect a performance as possible. I wouldn't go that far as things can always be better, but Jess was pretty darn good!
8:33 When you are a jazz dancer, you focus on the big movements and the energy. But in a Broadway specific routine, you need to focus much more on the small details and perfect those small moments.
8:32 Obviously Megan loved the Broadway routine. She commented on Jess's showmanship and Clarice's sass. I'll give her props for that. Nigel agreed with me...that Clarice was missing a little bit of the nuance of the routine.
8:31 Oh my lord we have a Liza moment with Me And My Baby from Chicago. I like the simplicity of this routine and the fact that it allows the dancers to focus on the intricacies and specifics. Jess has the Fosse style down and Clarice could stand do round her shoulders a little more, but a good start overall.
8:30 Jess is officially my new favorite because he has been in 3 Broadway shows.
8:29 Our next pairing is Clarice & Jess and they are doing a Tyce Diorio Broadway routine! I love how so many of these couples are "randomly" drawing their own styles.
8:22 I'm loving Megan's comments on the performances...she should come back! She is calling it as she sees it and points on that Sasha is a favorite and Alexander needs to show the emotion that is in his body on his face.
8:21 As Mary commented, Alexander really slammed to the floor on that last movement. Mary is gushing over Travis's choreography and while I don't think he is as special as they all believe, I do agree with her that his transitions are great and each movement moves seamlessly into the next.
8:20 Sasha is beastly....she is like a dancing Xena!
8:18 They have a gorgeous fluidity to their movements. Tremendous performance quality: Sasha is so aggressive and Alexander looks as if he isn't in his right mind. The choreography is not doing much for me. It's the same old thing we always see from Travis.
8:16 Sasha is up for our next couple & she's paired with Alexander. Both are contemporary-ish dancers. They'll be doing a Travis Wall contemporary routine so that should be old hat for them. The rehearsal footage shows Sasha basically attacking Alexander so we'll see how that translates to the routine.
8:11 That number was a good start to the season. Those two have similar body types as weird as it sounds and I'd really like to see them partner in the future. I can see them fitting well into a Mia Michaels routine the way that they were throwing one another around in that piece!
8:10 Mary looks like she is about to cry already. Its going to be a loooooong season. Megan is giving very specific comments rather than a general sweep of the routine. She definitely has some chops for this and it sounds like she knows her stuff!
8:07 These two look very good together when they are dancing separately but the partnering is very awkward and clunky. They have great aggressive energy toward the beginning but they started losing it toward the end. Overall it was a strong opening to the season and I liked the style overall.
8:06 We have jazzer Jordan and hiphopper Tadd doing Afro-Jazz, which Tadd called "destructive.
8:05 We haven't even seen the first performances and we already have one injury. Mitchell injured his elbow after his first rehearsal. Dear lord let's hope that is the only injury of the season and not like that mess last season.
8:03 Megan Mullally is guest judging tonight and she looks exactly like Karen Walker. I keep forgetting that Megan studied at SAB. Though she does indeed have a technical background, I suspect she'll be commenting mostly on performance.
8:00 The dancers always look so darn excited in their intro dances on the first episode of the season, its so cute! We always see huge tricks, lots of turns, leaps, and tumbles.